NY| New York Department of Financial Services Insurance Circular Letter No. 5, issued August 13, 2026, provides guidance on amendments to the state’s independent dispute resolution (IDR) process for out-of-network emergency services and surprise medical bills. Most changes apply to disputes submitted on or after August 26, 2026, and address eligibility, payment determinations, administrative fees, and decision deadlines. The letter also emphasizes that issuers and providers must submit relevant documentation at the beginning of the dispute process or when requested by the IDR entity.
- Eligibility changes: Medicaid Managed Care disputes filed on or after May 28, 2026, are excluded. The Empire Plan and Student Employee Health Plan enter the state IDR process beginning August 26, 2026, subject to eligibility requirements. Disputes are also ineligible when an issuer demonstrates an applicable provider contract or a qualifying prior-authorization notice identifying the disputed services as out-of-network.
- State Plan payment standards: For covered State Plan disputes, IDR entities generally select the payment offer closest to the 50th percentile of comparable in-network allowed amounts, with total payment capped at the 80th percentile when the provider’s fee is selected. Exceptions apply, including different criteria for certain hospital-employed or affiliated physicians.
- Fees and deadlines: Both parties must pay the IDR entity’s fee upfront, and IDR entities must keep those funds in a separate account. Refunds generally must be issued within 30 days after a determination or ineligibility rejection, subject to applicable processing fees and prorated-refund rules. The decision deadline changes from 30 business days after application receipt to 45 business days after receipt of all information the IDR entity determines necessary.